TLDR: CookieYes offers extensive customization and strong WordPress integration. GetCookies loads a ~1.6 KB loader first, handles Consent Mode v2 automatically, and has no page limits on the free tier.
Read full summary
CookieYes is popular for its WordPress plugin and extensive customization options. GetCookies prioritizes performance and automatic configuration. Choose based on whether you need visual customization or maximum performance.
Summary by Claude AI
Customization vs. Simplicity
CookieYes offers dozens of banner layouts, extensive theming, and granular control over every visual aspect.
GetCookies offers clean defaults that work out of the box.
Both approaches have their place. The right choice depends on what you value.
The Quick Comparison
| Feature | GetCookies | CookieYes |
|---|---|---|
| Bundle Size | ~1.6 KB loader | ~30KB |
| Setup Time | 5 minutes | 15-20 minutes |
| WordPress Plugin | Yes | Yes (more established) |
| Shopify App | Yes | Yes |
| Free Tier | Unlimited pages | 100 pages |
| Consent Mode v2 | Automatic | Requires setup |
| Customization | Good | Extensive |
Free Tier Showdown
GetCookies Free
- 1 domain
- Unlimited page views
- All core features
- Google Consent Mode v2 included
- Third-party pixel integration
CookieYes Free
- 1 domain
- 100 pages limit
- Basic features
- Upgrades required for Consent Mode
Winner: GetCookies. No page limits, full features.
A growing blog with 500 pages needs CookieYes paid ($10/month) but works on GetCookies free.
Bundle Size
GetCookies
- ~1.6 KB synchronous loader
- Widget loads async after page render
- Minimal LCP impact
CookieYes
- ~30KB full load
- Good, but not minimal
- Some LCP impact on slower connections
On mobile 3G, that's ~8ms vs ~200ms download time.
WordPress Integration
Both have WordPress plugins. CookieYes is more established in the WordPress ecosystem.
CookieYes WordPress
- Long-established plugin
- Extensive settings panel
- Popular in WP community
- More reviews and ratings
- Deeper WP-specific features
GetCookies WordPress
- Simple, lightweight plugin
- Dashboard configuration
- Quick setup
- Less WP-specific bloat
If WordPress is your primary platform and you want extensive WP-specific features, CookieYes has the edge.
If you want minimal plugin overhead, GetCookies is leaner.
Google Consent Mode v2
GetCookies
<!-- Automatic, no configuration -->
<script src="https://getcookies.co/api/v1/widget/loader.js"
data-domain-id="YOUR_DOMAIN_ID"
async></script>
Developer ID registered. All v2 signals set automatically. Updates on consent change without configuration.
CookieYes
- Available in paid plans
- Requires dashboard configuration
- Additional steps for GTM
- Testing needed
GetCookies wins for zero-config Consent Mode.
Customization
CookieYes
- Extensive theming options
- Multiple banner layouts
- Widget customization
- Granular control over every element
- Template library
If you need pixel-perfect control over banner appearance, CookieYes delivers.
GetCookies
- Color customization
- Position options
- Text customization
- CSS override support
- Clean, professional defaults
GetCookies covers the common customizations. For most sites, the defaults work well.
Third-Party Pixel Integration
GetCookies
Built-in automatic integration:
// Happens automatically when consent changes
fbq('consent', 'grant'); // Meta
ttq.enableCookie(); // TikTok
pintrk('set', {...}); // Pinterest
// etc.
No configuration. Pixels are notified automatically.
CookieYes
- Manual configuration
- GTM integration required
- Trigger setup for each pixel
Pricing
GetCookies
| Plan | Monthly | Domains |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 1 (unlimited pages) |
| Starter | $9 | 3 |
| Professional | $29 | 10 |
| Agency | $79 | Unlimited |
CookieYes
| Plan | Monthly | Domains |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 1 (100 pages) |
| Basic | $10 | 1 |
| Plus | $25 | 3 |
| Pro | $50 | 10 |
Similar pricing at paid tiers, but:
- GetCookies free has no page limits
- GetCookies Professional ($29) gives 10 domains vs CookieYes Pro ($50)
Developer Experience
GetCookies
// Clean, modern API
window.GetCookies.hasConsent('analytics')
window.GetCookies.showPreferences()
// Event-driven
window.addEventListener('getcookies:consent', (e) => {
const { analytics, marketing } = e.detail;
});
CookieYes
// Event-based
document.addEventListener("cookieyes_consent_update", function(e) {
const consent = e.detail;
});
Both work. GetCookies API feels slightly more intuitive.
When to Choose CookieYes
Choose CookieYes if:
- You need extensive visual customization
- WordPress is your main platform
- You want more template options
- You need CookieYes-specific integrations
- Visual banner control is a priority
When to Choose GetCookies
Choose GetCookies if:
- Performance is priority
- You want automatic Consent Mode v2
- Minimal configuration is preferred
- Third-party pixel auto-integration matters
- You're a developer or startup
Migration Path
From CookieYes to GetCookies
<!-- Remove CookieYes -->
<script id="cookieyes" src="..."></script>
<!-- Add GetCookies -->
<script src="https://getcookies.co/api/v1/widget/loader.js"
data-domain-id="YOUR_DOMAIN_ID"
async></script>
Previous consent doesn't transfer (users see banner once), but compliance is immediate.
WordPress Migration
- Deactivate CookieYes plugin
- Install GetCookies plugin
- Enter domain ID
- Activate
Performance Comparison
| Metric | GetCookies | CookieYes |
|---|---|---|
| Initial load | ~1.6 KB | ~30KB |
| LCP impact | Minimal | Some |
| Lighthouse hit | 0-2 points | 3-8 points |
The Verdict
CookieYes is a solid CMP with extensive customization and strong WordPress roots. If visual control over your banner is important and you're on WordPress, it's a good choice.
GetCookies is built for performance and simplicity. A ~1.6 KB loader, with the ~20 KB banner loaded asynchronously. Automatic Consent Mode v2. No page limits on free tier.
Choose based on what matters most: customization depth or performance focus.
Ready for the performance-first approach?